Skip to main content

Sell or Keep Renting? Twin Cities Numbers for Out of State Landlords

Deciding to sell or keep renting as an out of state landlord comes down to cash flow, repairs coming due and taxes on a sale. There's a middle option too.

Landlord reviewing rental spreadsheets on a laptop

Should you sell your Twin Cities rental?

If you own a rental here and live somewhere else, you’ve probably asked this more than once. Usually right after a 2 a.m. call about a furnace. The answer is in the numbers, and a lot of owners who live out of state skip some of them. Here’s how to run all of them. If you decide to sell your rental property, we buy with tenants in place.

Step 1: Your real cash flow

LineMonthly example
Rent collected (not asking rent)$1,850
Property management (around 10%)-$185
Property taxes-$290
Insurance-$120
Routine maintenance-$150
Set aside for vacancy and turnover-$110
Mortgage payment-$780
Cash flow$215

$215 a month is $2,580 a year. And that’s before any big repair.

Step 2: Big repairs coming due

Aging furnace and water heater in a rental basement

Roofs, furnaces, water heaters, windows and sewer lines don’t show up in monthly cash flow until they fail. A $14,000 roof in the next two years wipes out more than five years of that $215 a month. List what’s coming.

Step 3: Return on your equity

Say the house is worth $300,000 and you owe $120,000. You have $180,000 of equity earning $2,580 a year, about 1.4%, plus appreciation and loan paydown. Compare that with what the same money could do elsewhere, with no tenants.

Single family rental house needing paint

Step 4: Taxes on a sale

  • Capital gains on appreciation.
  • Depreciation recapture, which is tax on the depreciation you took, or could have taken, while you rented it out.
  • Minnesota income tax on the gain, wherever you live now.
  • A 1031 exchange can put off the tax. You have 45 days to name a replacement investment property in writing and 180 days to close on it.

Have your CPA estimate what you’d keep after taxes before you decide.

Step 5: The middle option

Want income without being a landlord? Seller financing or a contract for deed lets you sell the house and get paid monthly, with interest. You carry the risk that the buyer stops paying. But there are no tenants, no repairs and no midnight calls. See seller financing vs. cash.

A quick decision guide

If this is trueConsider
Strong cash flow, no big repairs due, you like itKeep
Thin cash flow, big repairs coming, managing is wearing on youSell
Want income, not tenantsSeller financing or contract for deed
Want to stay invested, but not in a house you manageA 1031 exchange into something easier to own
Problem tenant or repairs you’ve put offSell as is with tenants in place

The questions that settle it for most owners

Numbers matter, but so does your life. Ask yourself these honestly:

  • How many hours a month does this rental actually take? Include the calls, the texts, the contractor chasing and the worry.
  • What happens if the furnace dies in January and you’re 1,500 miles away? Do you have someone you trust to handle it?
  • Would you buy this property today, at today’s price, as an investment? If not, that tells you something.
  • What’s your plan for the next five years? If you’ll sell at some point anyway, the only real question is when.
  • Is the property manager working for you? Rising costs and slow responses are common reasons owners decide to sell.

Keeping it? Then tighten the management agreement, set money aside for big repairs and schedule them. If you want out, compare three paths. Sell vacant after a lease ends, sell occupied to an investor, or sell to us as is with tenants in place. Each one nets a different number on a different timeline.

How we help

Ryan will lay out three options side by side: a cash sale with tenants in place, a listing, and seller financing. He works from your real rent roll and repair list, and he’ll tell you which one wins and why. You and your CPA can take it from there.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

What is depreciation recapture?

When you sell a rental, the depreciation you took (or could have taken) is usually taxed separately from capital gains, often at a different rate. Ask your CPA for your numbers.

Can I do a 1031 exchange?

Possibly, if you buy another investment property within strict deadlines using a qualified intermediary. It delays the tax. It doesn't erase it.

Is it worth keeping a rental from out of state?

Run the real cash flow after management, maintenance, capital repairs and vacancy. Many owners who live out of state find the return on their equity is lower than they thought.

Can I get monthly income without being a landlord?

Yes, through seller financing or a contract for deed. You're a lender, not a landlord.

See how we work with tired landlords

Nonpaying tenants, squatters, vacant units, repairs that got put off, owners who live out of state. We buy with tenants in place, and no eviction is needed.

See My Rental Options
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address