Skip to main content

Seller Financing vs. Cash Sale: When Carrying the Note Nets More

Seller financing vs. a cash sale, worked out on a paid off Roseville rambler. What each one nets, and what happens if the buyer stops paying.

Homeowner reviewing a payment schedule at a kitchen table

Should you carry the note or take cash?

If you own your house free and clear, or close to it, you have a choice most sellers don’t. You can take one lump sum, or become the lender and get paid monthly with interest. Seller financing, one of our creative financing options, usually brings in more total dollars. A cash sale is fast and certain. Here’s how to compare them.

A worked example

Say you have a 1962 rambler in Roseville with no mortgage. In its current condition, it would sell for about $300,000 on the open market.

Option A: Cash sale to us

LineAmount
Cash price$232,000
Commission and closing costs$0
What you get at closing$232,000

Option B: Seller financing to us

LineAmount
Price$275,000
Down payment at closing$30,000
What the buyer owes you$245,000
Interest rate and term6%, payments figured over 30 years, balloon due at year 7
Monthly payment to youAbout $1,469
Payments over 7 yearsAbout $123,400
Final lump sum (balloon) at year 7About $220,000
Total received, down payment includedAbout $373,000

Paid off Twin Cities rambler on a clear day

On paper, seller financing brings in far more. But compare fairly: $232,000 invested today would grow over seven years too. And the note carries risk.

What you trade for the higher total

Scroll to compare

ComparisonCash saleSeller financing
Money at closingAll of itDown payment only
Total dollarsLowerHigher
Time until you’re paid in full7 to 14 daysYears
Risk after closingNoneThe buyer stops paying
Monthly incomeNoneYes
TaxesAny taxable gain in one yearPossibly spread out as an installment sale
Work for youNoneWatching payments, taxes, insurance

Protecting yourself if the buyer stops paying

  • Bigger down payment. More skin in the game, less risk.
  • Shorter balloon. The sooner you’re paid in full, the less time your money is at risk.
  • An outside servicing company. It tracks and reports the payments, so you’re not keeping a ledger at the kitchen table.
  • Insurance and tax escrow. So a missed bill doesn’t surprise you.
  • Recorded mortgage or contract. So your claim on the house is on public record.
  • A clear fallback. You can foreclose on a mortgage you hold, or cancel a contract for deed under Minn. Stat. 559.21.

Signed promissory note and mortgage with a notary stamp

Who seller financing fits

  • You own the house outright or have a small balance
  • Monthly income appeals to you, often in retirement
  • You don’t need the full amount now
  • Some risk is fine with you in exchange for more money

Who should take the cash

  • You need the money now for a new home, debt or care
  • You can’t afford a default
  • After closing, you’d rather not think about the house again

How we handle it

When we buy with seller financing, we put the terms in writing. The paperwork is a promissory note and a recorded mortgage or contract, and we set up servicing. We want your attorney to review all of it. Ryan lays those terms out next to our straight cash offer and what a listing would net, and tells you which one wins and why. Ask your tax professional if it can be treated as an installment sale. Then pick.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Does seller financing net more than cash?

Often in total dollars, since you usually get a higher price plus interest over time. What you give up is time, and you take on the risk that the buyer stops paying.

What interest rate is typical?

It's negotiated. It comes down to the down payment, the buyer's situation, the term and current mortgage rates. Higher risk usually means a higher rate.

What if the buyer defaults?

Depending on the structure, you can foreclose on a mortgage you hold or cancel a contract for deed under Minn. Stat. 559.21. A bigger down payment lowers that risk.

How are taxes handled?

Sales with seller financing can often be reported as installment sales. That spreads the taxable gain over the years you get paid (IRS Publication 537). If it was your home, the home sale exclusion may cover much of the gain anyway. Ask your tax professional.

See how creative financing works with us

Subject-to, seller financing or contract for deed. Keep your equity and get relief from the payments. Downside: it's more complex.

See Creative Financing
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address