Skip to main content

When NOT to Sell Your House to a Cash Buyer, Us Included

Here's when not to sell to a cash buyer, and what to do instead.

Illustration of a buyer and a homeowner comparing printed options at a kitchen table

Why would a cash buyer tell you not to sell to them?

Our cash offer is the right answer for some houses and some deadlines. For a lot of others, one of our other three paths puts more money in your pocket. Below are the cases where that’s true, with numbers, so you can spot yourself in one.

The short version: if you have time, a house in decent shape, and no title or tenant problem, you should probably list. Is the problem temporary, and can you qualify for a loan? Then look hard at refinancing. And with a low rate on your mortgage and little equity, a creative deal may beat cash.

A well kept 1950s rambler with a for sale sign

About the examples: The people and figures below are made up examples, not real client stories or estimates for your house. They show how the choices play out. Use current local sales and your own costs before deciding.

Case 1: A house in decent shape and 60 days to spare

Linda owns a 1956 rambler in Richfield. New roof in 2019, updated furnace, original kitchen that’s dated but clean. She’s moving to be near her daughter in the spring and isn’t in a rush.

  • Our cash offer: around $232,000, since we’d still update the kitchen, bath and flooring.
  • Listing with Ryan: a realistic sale price around $300,000. She’d pay about $16,500 in commission (5.5%), $4,500 in deed tax, title and closing fees, and $5,000 for light prep. Three months of holding costs at $1,800 a month add $5,400. After all that, she nets about $268,600.

Listing wins by more than $35,000. Ryan would tell Linda to list the house with him, and he’d walk her through both numbers so she can see the gap for herself.

Signs this is you: a buyer’s inspection would turn up only minor items. You can wait 30 to 60 days to get under contract. And you can keep the house ready for showings (or it’s already empty).

The honest rule

When a house needs little work and you have time, regular buyers will beat an investor’s price nearly every time. That goes for us, and for every cash buyer who sends you a postcard.

Case 2: A temporary problem you can fix

Marcus fell three payments behind after a layoff last winter. He started a new job in June, his income is back, and he has about 35% equity in a Coon Rapids split level. He’s scared, and a cash buyer’s letter made selling sound like the only way out.

It isn’t. With steady income and real equity, he has better options. He can catch up on the loan, get a loan modification from his servicer, or refinance to keep the house once his payment history recovers. Selling at a discount to fix a problem that lasted six months would cost him the equity he spent years building. We don’t make a dime on that path, and Ryan would still recommend it.

Signs this is you: whatever caused the hardship is over, your income is steady again, and you have real equity. Give the Minnesota Homeownership Center a call too. They can connect you with a free counselor approved by HUD.

Case 3: Low rate, little equity, and a move you can’t avoid

Priya bought a Maple Grove townhome in 2021 with a 3% mortgage. She’s moving for work. The home would sell for about what she owes. If she listed it, she’d have to bring a check to closing to cover commission and other costs. A cash sale would be even worse.

Creative financing may fit better. In a subject-to sale, the loan stays in her name and the buyer makes the payments. She walks away without writing a check at closing. The risk is real (the lender could call the loan due), and she’d want an attorney to review it first. But on the numbers, it can beat both listing and cash. Read more about creative financing and what a subject-to sale is.

Signs this is you: a mortgage rate well below today’s, a balance close to the home’s value, and a reason you can’t stay.

Side by side net sheets for a cash sale and a listing

When a cash sale really is the right answer

Cash does win sometimes. It wouldn’t be fair to pretend otherwise, and it usually wins when:

SituationWhy cash tends to win
A sheriff’s sale or redemption deadlineCloses in 7 to 14 days; no buyer financing to fall through
Major repairs (foundation, roof, fire, 60 amp panel)A buyer’s lender often won’t close until it’s fixed
House packed full of belongingsNo cleanout, no staging
Liens, probate gaps or title problemsWe fix the title instead of walking away
Tenants who won’t pay or leaveWe buy with tenants in place
You need a closing date you can count onNo appraisal, no inspection contingency

Even then, run the numbers. The cash vs. list net sheet shows how repairs, commission and holding time change the gap. Or plug in your own house on the free calculator.

How to tell which one is you

Ask yourself four questions:

  1. How much time do I have? Under 30 days points toward cash. If you’ve got 60 days or more, listing is on the table.
  2. What would a buyer’s inspector find? Minor items point toward listing. Structural, roof, electrical or water problems point toward cash or listing to investors.
  3. Is the problem temporary? If yes, and you can qualify, look hard at keeping the house.
  4. What’s my rate and equity? A low rate plus low equity points toward creative financing.

Then ask Ryan. He’ll walk you through all four paths, lay them out plainly and tell you which one wins and why. Sometimes that means we send you to a lender instead.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Why would you tell me not to sell to you?

Two reasons. If you net more somewhere else and you hear it from us, we've earned your trust. And maybe someday you send us a neighbor whose house does need a cash buyer. We have four paths, and a cash sale is only one of them. Ryan's job is to find the one that wins for you.

How much more does listing usually net?

That comes down to repairs, time and commission. On a house in decent shape, listing often nets tens of thousands more. On a house that needs major work, the gap shrinks or disappears once repairs and holding costs are counted. Run the net sheet with your own numbers.

What if I need to move in two weeks?

Then speed may be worth the discount. A cash sale closes in 7 to 14 days. A listing takes 30 to 60 days to get under contract and longer to close.

Can I get your cash offer and still list with Ryan?

Yes. The cash offer becomes your floor, and the listing has to beat it.

Compare all four paths for your house

Our cash offer may not be your best option. Ryan will explain when listing, creative financing or a refinance makes more sense, even when you choose not to sell to us.

See All Four Paths
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address