Skip to main content

Cash Offer vs. Listing: Net Sheet on a $300K Twin Cities House

Here's a cash offer vs. listing net sheet on a $300K house, line by line: commission, repairs, holding time, closing costs and days to cash.

A printed net sheet and calculator on a kitchen counter

What does each path actually put in your pocket?

The sale price isn’t what you keep. What you keep is the net: the price minus everything it costs to get there. Take one $300,000 Twin Cities house and sell it two ways: to us for cash, or through a listing with Ryan on NorthstarMLS. If the two nets are close, speed and certainty might decide it. If they’re far apart, the math decides it. Cash and listing are two of our four paths.

A split level suburban Minnesota house in fall

The example house

A 1978 split level in Burnsville. Three bedrooms, two baths, original kitchen, a furnace that’s 17 years old, and a roof with a few years left. Going by recent sales of similar houses nearby, it would sell for around $300,000 in its current shape with light prep. The owner has 60 to 90 days to work with.

The two net sheets, side by side

Scroll to compare

Line itemListing with RyanCash sale to us
Sale price$300,000$235,000
Commission (5.5% example)-$16,500$0
Deed tax, title and closing fees (about 1.5%)-$4,500$0, we pay them
Prep and repairs before listing-$8,000$0
Holding costs (3 months at $1,800)-$5,400-$900 (about 2 weeks)
Moving help$0+$1,000
Net before mortgage payoff$265,600$235,100
Days to cashAbout 907 to 14

In this example, listing nets about $30,000 more. That’s a lot of money, and for most sellers in this spot, listing is the right call. Ryan would say so.

What the table doesn’t show

Listing comes with risks that never show up on a net sheet. The buyer’s inspection can reopen the price, the appraisal can come in low, or the loan can fall through a week before closing. A cash sale to us skips those three. Is that certainty worth the difference? That’s your call.

What changes the answer

The gap moves fast when the house or the timeline changes.

More repairs. Say the same house needed a $25,000 roof and a $12,000 furnace before a buyer’s lender would sign off. Your prep costs jump, and the sale price may still drop. The gap can shrink to a few thousand dollars.

Less time. Have to close in three weeks? Then listing isn’t really an option. It’s cash vs. a price cut to find a fast buyer.

Higher holding costs. A vacant house in winter with a mortgage, utilities and insurance can cost $2,500 or more a month. Every extra month eats the listing advantage.

A buyer who falls through. Losing a buyer after 30 days under contract resets the clock. Two more months at $1,800 costs $3,600. And that’s before you count the stress.

Calendar comparing a two week closing with a three month listing timeline

Minnesota costs to know about

  • State deed tax: about 0.33% of the sale price, typically paid by the seller. Hennepin and Ramsey counties add a small environmental fee on top.
  • City inspections before a sale: Minneapolis and St. Paul both make sellers pay up front for a Truth in Sale of Housing evaluation. Minneapolis can flag repairs you have to make. St. Paul’s report is disclosure only.
  • Radon, well and septic disclosures: separate from the main seller disclosure. They don’t cost anything, but they’re one more step.
  • Title insurance and closing fee: split between buyer and seller depending on the contract.

For every fee in detail, see the cost to sell a house in Minnesota.

When each path wins

Listing usually wins whenCash usually wins when
The house is in decent shapeRepairs are big enough to block a buyer’s loan
You have 60+ daysYou have a deadline under 30 days
You can handle showingsThe house is full of stuff, has tenants, or sits empty in winter
Title is cleanLiens, probate gaps or a foreclosure are involved

How to run your own numbers

Plug in your own list price estimate, commission, repair list and monthly costs. Our free cash vs. list net sheet calculator does the math. Or ask Ryan. He’ll walk you through what the house could list for, what you’d net by listing it, and our cash offer. Then he’ll tell you straight which one comes out ahead. You can list with Ryan or sell for cash, and you’ll know exactly what you gave up either way.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Does a cash sale mean less money?

Usually the price is lower, yes. But the gap narrows once you count commission, repairs, holding costs and closing costs on a listing. On a house that needs major work, the nets can end up close.

What closing costs do Minnesota sellers pay?

Usually the state deed tax, about 0.33% of the price (a little more in Hennepin and Ramsey counties). Then title and closing fees, plus property taxes owed up to the closing date. On our cash sales, we pay the deed tax and closing costs.

How long until I have the money?

Cash: 7 to 14 days. Listing: often 60 to 90 days from listing to closing, sometimes longer.

Does the net sheet include my mortgage payoff?

No. The example stops before the mortgage payoff, since you pay that off either way. Subtract your payoff from either net to see what lands in your account.

Compare all four paths for your house

An offer alone does not show what you will keep. Ryan compares the cash sale net with listing, creative financing and refinancing for your house.

See All Four Paths
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address