Skip to main content

Underwater on Your Mortgage: Short Sale vs. Cash Sale vs. Foreclosure

Short sale vs. cash sale vs. foreclosure in Minnesota: what each one means for lender approval, leftover debt, your credit and your timeline.

Couple reviewing a comparison sheet at a dining table

What are your options when you owe more than the house is worth?

When your mortgage balance is higher than what the house will sell for, a normal sale doesn’t work: the price can’t pay off the loan. That leaves a handful of exits, and none of them are painless. Below, we line them up side by side so you can pick the one that hurts least. If a foreclosure has already started, see facing foreclosure for the timeline.

Your options

Short sale. You sell for less than you owe, and the lender agrees to take what the sale brings in and release its lien. You need the lender’s approval. The buyer can be a cash buyer like us, so there’s no buyer loan to fall through.

Foreclosure. The lender takes the house through the sheriff’s sale. In Minnesota you usually have a redemption period afterward.

Subject-to. A buyer takes over the house and your payments, and the loan stays in your name. You don’t need the lender’s OK to transfer. But the lender can call the whole loan due once the house changes hands, and that risk is real.

Loan modification. Keep the house with new terms from your lender.

Bring cash to closing. Sell normally and pay the difference yourself.

Deed in lieu of foreclosure. You give the house back to the lender. It has to agree, and not every lender will.

Suburban Minnesota house with a bare maple in late fall

Side by side

Scroll to compare

ComparisonShort saleForeclosureBuyer takes over paymentsLoan modification
Lender approval neededYesNoNot for the transferYes
Typical timelineMonthsA year or more until redemption ends2 to 4 weeks1 to 3 months
Hit to your creditSerious, but usually less than foreclosureSevereDepends on whether the payments keep comingMild to moderate
Risk you still owe moneyDepends on approval termsDepends on foreclosure typeLoan stays yoursNone if you keep paying
You keep the houseNoNoNoYes
Main riskLender says no or drags its feetLosing everythingLender calls the loan due, or the buyer stops payingCan’t afford the new payment

How a short sale works

  1. Hardship package. You send the lender a hardship letter, income and expense documents, bank statements and tax returns.
  2. Purchase agreement. A buyer signs, but the deal only goes through if the lender approves.
  3. Lender review. The lender gets its own estimate of the value, looks at the offer, then approves it, counters or says no.
  4. Approval letter. Read it carefully. Does it forgive the leftover debt (the deficiency)? What do you have to sign?
  5. Closing. The lender gets the money from the sale and releases its lien.

Short sale approval letter from a lender

Short sales take time. If a sheriff’s sale is scheduled, ask the lender in writing if it will postpone the sale during its review. Don’t assume it will.

When a payment takeover makes sense

Say your balance is close to the value, your rate is low and you need out. Having a buyer take over your payments can be faster and less damaging than a short sale. The loan stays in your name, and the buyer makes the payments.

The risk: the lender can call the loan due once the house changes hands. And if payments stop, your credit takes the hit. Ryan explains both risks plainly before you sign. We record the documents and use an outside servicing company so you can see every payment.

Leftover debt (deficiency) in Minnesota

A deficiency is the gap between what you owed and what the lender got back. Can the lender come after you for it? That comes down to the type of foreclosure and the terms of any short sale approval.

In Minnesota, a lender that forecloses by advertisement, without going to court, usually can’t sue you for the rest on a typical home loan (Minn. Stat. 582.30). Court foreclosures and short sales work differently. Ask an attorney about your specific loan, and get any waiver in writing.

Canceled debt and taxes

Forgiven mortgage debt can count as taxable income, and the exceptions have changed over the years. Ask a tax professional before you close a short sale.

How to choose

  • Want to keep the house and can afford a modified payment? Loan modification.
  • Low rate, need out fast, and okay with the lender maybe calling the loan due? Subject-to.
  • Deeply underwater, lender willing to work with you, and time to wait? Short sale.
  • Nothing else works? Foreclosure, with the redemption period as your last window.

Ryan will lay out each one with your numbers and your dates, and tell you which one hurts least and why.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Is a short sale better than foreclosure?

Often, yes, for your credit and for control of the process. What you might still owe comes down to the lender's approval terms and the type of foreclosure. Read the short sale approval letter closely.

Can you buy an underwater house?

Yes, through a short sale with lender approval, or by taking over your payments with your loan left in place. Ryan compares both with numbers.

How long does a short sale take?

Often months, since the lender has to review and approve the price. Some move faster. Start early if a sheriff's sale is scheduled.

Will I owe money after a short sale?

Possibly. The lender may or may not forgive the rest of the debt. Get a written release before closing, and ask a tax professional about any canceled debt.

See how we help when you’re facing foreclosure

Behind on payments or facing a sheriff's sale? There's more than one way out, and one may let you keep the house.

See Foreclosure Options
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address