Skip to main content

When Siblings Disagree About Selling an Inherited House

When siblings disagree on an inherited house, start by putting everyone on the same numbers. Then look at a buyout, what the personal representative can decide, and partition as the last resort.

Adult siblings talking at a family kitchen table

Why do siblings disagree about the house?

Usually it’s not that anyone is being unreasonable. One sibling grew up there and can’t stand the idea of selling. Another lives in Denver and just wants it done. One heard the house is worth $400,000, and another got a $240,000 postcard offer. And one of them is living in it.

Often they’re working from different information, different ties to the house and different money situations. Our page on selling inherited property covers the full process, and this guide is about getting the family to one decision.

When it gets heated, each heir may want their own attorney.

Step 1: Get everyone the same numbers

Most arguments shrink when everyone’s looking at one set of numbers. Ryan walks the personal representative and every heir through the same comparison:

Scroll to compare

PathNet to the estateTimeWork for the family
Cash sale to usLower price, no costs7 to 14 daysVery little
List with RyanHigher price, minus commission, repairs and holding costs2 to 4 monthsPrep, showings, decisions
Buyout by one siblingBased on a CMA or appraisalDepends on their loanOne sibling takes on the house
Keep as a rentalMonthly income minus costsOngoingSomeone has to manage it

Printed four column comparison sheet on a table

Step 2: Consider a buyout

If one sibling wants to keep the house, a buyout is often the cleanest answer. The steps:

  1. Agree on value. Use an appraisal or a CMA (a comparison to recent sales). Some families knock off the costs a sale would have had, since the buying sibling skips commission and repairs.
  2. Figure the shares. Based on the will, or Minnesota’s rules for when there’s no will.
  3. Financing. The buying sibling usually needs a mortgage to pay out the others.
  4. Close it properly. Through a title company, with a deed and a settlement statement.

Step 3: What the personal representative can do

During probate, the personal representative runs the estate. With unrestricted authority, a PR can usually sell the house without every heir agreeing. The exception: if the will leaves the house itself to someone, that person has to agree (Minn. Stat. 524.3-715). And a PR has to act in the estate’s best interest and keep the heirs informed.

That authority is a backstop, not a first move. Our guide on PR authority has the details.

Step 4: Know the last resort

If the house has already passed to the siblings as co-owners and they can’t agree, any one of them can ask a court for partition. The Minnesota Partition Act (Minn. Stat. ch. 558A) sets the rules. The court can divide the property, but with a single house it more often orders a sale and splits the money.

Here’s the thing, though. Partition is slow and expensive. Court costs, the referee and the lawyers get paid from the sale first. So each of you usually nets less than you would from a sale you agree on. Its real use is as a reason to settle.

Older family home with a porch in autumn

When one sibling lives in the house

This is the hardest version, since it’s someone’s home right now. Some options:

  • Buyout by the sibling who lives there.
  • Rent paid to the estate at a fair rate until the estate closes.
  • A date to move out, in writing, followed by a sale.
  • Sell and let them stay a short time after closing, if everyone agrees.

Get any arrangement in writing. Handshake deals between siblings are where the long fights start.

How we help

Ryan talks to the whole family, not just one sibling. He’ll walk the house with whoever wants to be there, send every heir the same numbers, and answer everyone’s questions the same way.

If one of you wants to buy out the others, he’ll give you a CMA. Listing nets the most? He’ll list it. And if a quick cash sale settles things, we can close in 7 to 14 days. The title company can pay out each heir’s share.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Can one sibling force a sale?

Sometimes. A personal representative with authority can usually sell during probate. After the house passes to the heirs as co-owners, any one of them can ask a court for partition. That can end in a sale the court orders. Both are last resorts. Agreeing is faster and cheaper.

How do we value a buyout?

With an appraisal or a comparative market analysis (CMA). Ryan can put together a CMA. Some families subtract the costs a sale would have had, like commission and repairs.

Can proceeds be split at closing?

Yes. The title company can pay each heir's share separately, following written directions from the personal representative or an agreement all the heirs sign.

One sibling lives in the house. What then?

That's common. They can buy the others out, agree on a date to move out before a sale, or pay rent to the estate. Put any arrangement in writing.

See how we help heirs sell inherited property

Heirs and executors, often out of state. We’re familiar with Hennepin and Ramsey probate, and you can close remotely.

See My Estate Options
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address