Skip to main content

Refinance vs. Loan Modification vs. Forbearance in Minnesota

Refinance vs. loan modification vs. forbearance: what each one takes, what it costs, how it hits your credit, and when selling fits better.

Homeowner on the phone with a lender taking notes

Which way of keeping the house fits you?

If you want to stay in your house, there are four main tools: refinance, loan modification, forbearance and reinstatement. They’re easy to mix up, but each one fits a different problem. Here’s a plain comparison, the same one Ryan walks through on our refinance options page. We make nothing on any of them.

Your servicer’s programs and your loan type set the actual rules.

The four tools

Refinance. A new loan from any lender replaces your current one. You qualify fresh on credit, income and equity.

Loan modification. After reviewing your hardship, your current servicer changes the terms for good, like the rate, length or balance.

Forbearance. Your servicer pauses or lowers your payments for a set time. The missed amount doesn’t go away, though. You pay it back later.

Reinstatement. You pay everything you’re behind, including fees, in one lump sum.

Side by side

Scroll to compare

ComparisonRefinanceLoan modificationForbearanceReinstatement
Who you work withAny lenderYour servicerYour servicerYour servicer
Good whenThe problem is over, and you have strong credit and equityHardship is ongoing, but you can afford a lower paymentHardship is short termYou have the cash to catch up
Needs a clean payment record latelyUsually yesNoNoNo
Needs equityYesNot usuallyNoNo
Hit to your creditNew credit check and new loanMay be reportedMay be reportedLate payments stay on your report
How long it takes30 to 60 days1 to 3 months, then a trial periodQuickRight away
CostLender closing costsUsually noneUsually noneEverything you’re behind, plus fees

Printed comparison chart of mortgage options next to a laptop

When each one fits

  • Laid off, now back at work, with equity: catch up (reinstate) if you can, then maybe refinance later.
  • Permanent drop in income: loan modification.
  • Medical leave for three months: forbearance.
  • Behind, with a sale date set: reinstatement, or a modification with the sale pushed back, and a backup plan to sell.

How to apply for a modification

  1. Call the servicer and ask for a mortgage assistance application.
  2. Write a hardship letter: what happened, when, and why it’s temporary or permanent.
  3. Gather documents: pay stubs, bank statements, tax returns, a budget.
  4. Turn everything in and keep proof you sent it.
  5. Check in every week. Missing documents are the most common reason things stall.

Hardship letter and bank statements on a table

Federal rules protect you here. Turn in a complete application more than 37 days before a foreclosure sale, and the servicer has to give you a decision within 30 days. It can’t go ahead with the sale in the meantime. A foreclosure prevention advisor through the Minnesota Homeownership Center can help you with the application for free.

When none of these work

If you can’t afford even a modified payment, or you have no equity and the servicer says no, keeping the house may not be realistic.

Then it’s about protecting what you can: a sale before the sheriff’s sale, a sale during redemption, or a subject-to deal. See how we help when you’re facing foreclosure.

Our role

Ryan will tell you straight which of these looks realistic and point you to free counseling. If a refinance fits, he’ll refer you to a lender at no fee to you. And he’ll show you what selling would net as a backup, so a “no” from the servicer doesn’t leave you out of time.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Which hurts credit least?

Staying current or catching up fast usually does the least harm. A modification or forbearance may show up on your credit report, depending on your situation and how the servicer reports it. A foreclosure does the most damage.

Can I get a modification if I'm behind?

Often, yes. Loan modifications are made for borrowers with a hardship, and many servicers review them when you're behind. Apply early and send in everything they ask for.

What is reinstatement?

Paying all missed payments, fees and costs to bring the loan current. In Minnesota you can reinstate any time before the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.30).

Where can I get free help?

The Minnesota Homeownership Center can put you in touch with a free foreclosure prevention advisor at 866-462-6466. An advisor can help you apply to your servicer.

See how we help with refinance options

If the problem is behind you, keep the house and lower the payment. Downside: you have to qualify.

See Ways to Keep It
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address