Skip to main content

Fix Before Selling or Sell As Is: Which Repairs Pay Back?

Fix before selling or sell as is? Run the Twin Cities numbers first: repair cost vs. value added for roofs, furnaces and 60 amp panels, plus holding costs.

Old 60 amp fuse panel in a Richfield rambler basement

Should you fix it or sell it as is?

It comes down to three things: which repairs, what they cost, and how much time you have. Some repairs pay back more than they cost, since they open the house up to buyers who need a loan. Others cost more than they add. And every month spent repairing is another month of mortgage, taxes, insurance and utilities. Got bigger problems than a roof and an old panel? See how we buy houses that need major repairs.

The two kinds of repairs

Loan blockers and safety items. Things an FHA or VA appraiser, or a careful inspector, tends to flag: a failing roof, unsafe electrical, missing handrails, a broken furnace, active leaks. Fixing these can bring in a lot more buyers.

Cosmetic updates. Paint, flooring, fixtures, kitchens and baths. Light cosmetic work often pays back. Big remodels usually don’t.

Common Twin Cities repairs, compared

Scroll to compare

RepairTypical costOften pays back?Why
Paint and deep cleanLowYesCheap, and the house looks a lot better
Roof at end of lifeHighOften, if buyers need financingA worn out roof can stop FHA and VA loans
60 amp panel upgradeModerateOftenInsurers and lenders flag old panels
Furnace replacementModerateSometimesBuyers expect working heat, but you can price it in
Drain tile and water fixModerate to highSometimesRemoves a big inspection worry
Kitchen remodelHighRarelyBuyers pay for it, but not dollar for dollar
Bath remodelModerate to highRarelySame as kitchens
Refinish hardwood floorsLow to moderateOftenFloors are one of the first things buyers notice

Roofer tearing off shingles on a Twin Cities house

The holding cost math

Say you spend $12,000 on a roof and panel to list a house for $305,000 instead of $285,000 as is. That’s $20,000 more on paper. But the work takes six weeks, adding about $3,000 in holding costs, and you’re managing contractors. Net gain: about $5,000, plus more buyers and less risk of a deal falling apart. Some sellers would take that. Others would rather not babysit contractors for six weeks to clear $5,000.

The three paths compared

Ryan puts these side by side for your house:

  1. Sell to us as is for cash. Jordan’s repair estimate is built into the offer. No work, 7 to 14 days.
  2. List it as is. Price it for cash buyers and investors on the MLS.
  3. Targeted repairs first. Only the fixes that pay back, then list it with Ryan.

Homeowner comparing contractor bids and a net sheet

When fixing first usually wins

  • You have time and some cash for repairs
  • The problems are a short list of things that block a buyer’s loan
  • The house is otherwise in good shape and in demand
  • You can manage contractors, or have someone who can

When selling as is usually wins

  • The repair list is long or structural
  • You don’t have the cash or time
  • You live out of state or the house sits empty through winter
  • There are other complications: liens, tenants, probate

City inspections before you sell

In Minneapolis, the Truth in Sale of Housing report can flag repairs that have to get done. You fix them, or a buyer agrees to finish them within 90 days of closing. So whatever path you pick, plan for them. Over in St. Paul, the city’s version is disclosure only. Our Truth in Sale of Housing guide covers both cities.

Don’t know which repairs pay back on your house? Jordan and Ryan will tell you. That advice is free, and so is the cash offer next to it.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to a Minnesota attorney or tax professional.

Questions sellers ask about this

Which repairs pay back most?

Safety items and anything that blocks a buyer's loan, like a failing roof or unsafe electrical, usually pay back. They open the house to more buyers. Cosmetic updates vary. Paint and cleaning usually pay back, and big remodels rarely do.

Should I replace the roof before selling?

Two things decide it: the roof's age and who's likely to buy. A roof at the end of its life can block FHA and VA loans. So if most of your likely buyers need a loan, replacing it may pay back. If not, pricing it in may be smarter.

What does it cost to wait on repairs?

Every month you're paying mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance and utilities. On many Twin Cities houses that's $1,500 to $2,500 a month, and projects have a way of running long.

Can Jordan price repairs if I list instead?

Yes. Jordan prices the work, and Ryan tells you which repairs are worth doing before you list.

See how we buy houses that need major repairs

Foundation, roof, water or fire damage, houses packed with belongings, code violations, mold, failed septic. We buy houses like these, and you fix nothing.

See My Repair Options
Your four options

Four ways out. Ryan tells you which one wins.

Ryan Quade, MN licensed salesperson #40924708 with Coldwell Banker Realty, walks you through all four with the numbers for your house.

Minnesota fact: in most foreclosures you can still sell during the six month redemption period after the sheriff's sale (Minn. Stat. 580.23).

Call Ryan Send My Address